Momentary Solutions

drape yourself in momentary solutions and keep on wishing you could be f l a w l e s s

reverse therapy – a step in the wrong direction

Before I get started, I’d like to state one important thing. Comments left by people who use fake email addresses will be deleted. I’ve had a LOT of bullshit left here by people with fake email addresses. If you want to share your opinion, disagree with mine, whatever, but you don’t have the balls to use your correct contact information so that I can reply to you (I do reply to people by email often), either don’t bother or expect your comment to be removed.

This is long, I know. But please read it. If you get to the end of this blog entry you will have a better understanding of things that affect my life and cause me to be the militant invisible-disability activist that I am. And I would appreciate it, a lot.

I’ve just seen something that made my blood boil. In fact, my blood continues to boil as I write this. It is Reverse-Therapy.com, a ‘cure’ for ME/CFS. I’m going to quote parts of the website so that it makes sense when I argue with them, but if you want to read the whole revolting thing, click on the link back there and keep a bucket handy in case you need to vomit. Which you probably will.

Apparently, “Reverse therapy is an educational process which teaches people how to eliminate symptoms by understanding and acting on ‘the message of the symptom’ – what Bodymind is trying to ’say’ through the symptoms in order to warn, guide and protect the individual.” The wonderful doctor (who I can only assume got his qualification from the bottom of a cereal box) says that “Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Fibromyalgia are triggered by the Hypothalamus overworking the Pituitary and Adrenal Glands, This is why Reverse Therapists refer to these conditions as ‘HPA Disorder’ – referring to the Hypothalamus-Pituitary-Adrenal axis.”

Ok, so first flaw in the logic. Dysfunction of the hypothalamus is a symptom of ME/CFS, not a cause (and IF research ever exists to suggest that it does have ’cause of condition’ status, it sure as hell isn’t caused by emotional blockages in the mind as reverse therapy claims). So this ‘reverse therapist’ (well done, make up a type of therapy and then make up a title for yourself to legitimise it) is actually basing his treatment on one symptom of an extremely complex physical condition. He actually redefines ME/CFS as ‘HPA disorder’…can we all start redefining illnesses to suit our own purpose? Cause if we can, I’d like to redefine ME as ‘lack of chocolate disorder’ and create my own therapy for it that revolves around eating chocolate and selling chocolate to other people who haven’t been under the supervision of a decent medical professional who took the time to explain their illness and who haven’t done any of their own research. Way to go, indoctrinate the impressionable and vulnerable. That’s what the world needs. He goes on to helpfully explain that

“Bodymind notices that the person is emotionally vulnerable in some way and sends emotions of various kinds to signal that action is required. This could involve taking more time out for oneself, saying ‘No’ to unreasonable demands, speaking up about personal needs, or doing more things to boost enjoyment and confidence.”

Yes dear, and learning to say ‘no’ to unreasonable demands will cure cancer too. Isn’t the world great? All we need to do is speak up about our personal needs and we will be miraculously cured of our physical ailments. Praise be! The most painful bit to read is this.

“But when Headmind interferes with this natural cycle by coming up with worries, predictions of disaster, or thinking that attention to emotional needs is ‘bad’ or ’selfish’ then the person becomes trapped. Bodymind notices that the person is in danger of emotional overload and so it uses the Hypothalamus to switch on an alarm response that produces the symptoms.”

And then,

“Headmind notices that symptoms are getting worse so it triggers an Anxiety response that leads the person to conclude that there is nothing they can do about the symptoms.”

Yes, you read that correctly. Apparently my headmind is triggering an anxiety response which is leading me to conclude that there is nothing I can do about my symptoms. Ummm…not quite, asshole. When I feel tired and worn out, I can rest or meditate. When I am in pain I can do stretches that ease my pain, or (god forbid!) take a couple of pain killers so that I can continue with the things I need to do. When I feel stressed (yes, anxious!) I can sit down, have a cup of tea, get my thoughts in order and remind myself that things aren’t as bad as they seem right now and I just need to take some time to chill out and deal with what’s going on. Does that sound like a conclusion that there is nothing I can do about my symptoms? No. But luckily,

“Reverse Therapy reverses symptoms by:

  • Getting the person to see that Headmind is keeping them trapped in Anxiety and Illness

  • Raising the client’s awareness of Bodymind and re-connecting to their emotional needs

  • Understanding and acting on ‘the message of the symptom’

  • Engaging in activities that boost confidence and happiness

  • Keeping a record of situations in which symptoms increase so that further work can be carried out on protecting the client in those situation.”

First of all, I am not ‘trapped’ in anxiety and illness. I have an illness which means I have to make adjustments to my life, but it absolutely does not trap me. I am perfectly connected to my emotional needs, thank you very much. The main one is ‘I need to NOT be made fuming mad by wankers who tell me that I am basically making/keeping myself sick’. As soon as I stopped reading Reverse-Therapy.com, that emotional need was met. It’s a fucking miracle! I fully understand the message of my symptoms. My back hurts. It’s telling me “You’ve over-done it today, you need to do some back stretches, sit comfortably and rest until it hurts less, then take it easy for the next couple of days”. And as for boosting confidence and happiness…living my life does that. I curl up on the couch with my husband and watch a movie, I hang out at a friend’s house, I take photographs, I go to a meeting to discuss a project I’m working on and guess what? I feel confident and happy! If I repeatedly tell myself that my illness is my fault, that it’s caused by a lack of understanding of myself, my body and my mind and I am deciding to remain sick then I DON’T feel confident and happy. See how this is working out?

What Mr Reverse Therapist is saying, shortened for ease of reading, is that he can help people who ARE trapped in a cycle of self-blame and self-inflicted misery, people who DO languish in a sick-role, to realise that they can, to a certain extent, control their body and their mind. This isn’t a bad thing. It’s true – while we can’t all fix things that go wrong with our body, we can learn to adjust and deal with these things in ways which make us happier and make our lives easier. I read some testimonials written for this guy and I’m willing to bet rather a lot of money (ok, I don’t have any money…I’m willing to bet some valued possessions) that they were written by people who, prior to their reverse therapy experience, had been the kind of people who sit around feeling sorry for themselves and rot in a pit of ‘poor me, I’m so sick, I can’t do anything’.

Most people who I’ve met, online and offline, who have or have had ME/CFS are extremely strong, determined, ambitious, resilient, optimistic people who have fought through useless doctors, useless specialists, useless medical insurance companies and a society full of people who either don’t understand or choose not to understand their condition. I have NEVER spoken to someone with ME/CFS who isn’t in touch with their mind or their body – this condition FORCES you to gain a deeper understanding of yourself because it’s the only way you can make the necessary adjustments to your life and keep on living.

Yes, there are people out there who DO fall into malaise and depression because they lack understanding of themselves and their life, who self-diagnose and convince themselves they have various medical conditions so that they can sit back and make excuses. People who blow a period of tiredness, an extended common cold, a slight backache, out of all proportion because they’re SICK, DAMMIT and want some attention. I have yet to meet an ME/CFS patient who falls into that category. But I’m sure if there are any, they would benefit very well from Reverse Therapy.

ME/CFS is NOT a psychological condition any more than cancer or hepatitis are. Yes, there are a range of ways in which symptoms can be eased or temporarily relieved and of course this involves a certain amount of thought, but that doesn’t mean that our feelings cause our illnesses. Perhaps instead of pandering to rich narcissistic hypochondriacs, Mr Reverse Therapy should go and write for Cosmopolitan and invent imaginary syndromes based on people’s feelings towards their boss or boyfriend or cat and the size of their thighs (or whatever the fuck it is the qualified professionals who work for that magazine do). If you’ll excuse me, I have clients to call, photographs to take, a car to tax, a husband to hug, two cats to feed and a very messy head of hair to wash. I’d better go and get in touch with my Headmind and Hypothalamus to make sure I can cope with all that, poor little self-inflictedly sick person that I am.

Or maybe I should take, ohhhh..about ten minutes to invent a type of therapy which I can sell to the vulnerable and scared and make myself a few million pounds. I could even get people to pay to learn how to do this therapy and patronise the unwell in their own part of the world. I bet if I focused this therapy around an illness that’s completely physical but still very misunderstood and convinced people to believe that it’s all in their mind I could make LOADS of money. Shit, someone beat me to it…

EDIT: Guess what? The dude isn’t a medical doctor. He has a doctorate in psychology which means he’s spent the last few years learning about what other psychologists have done and thought for the last hundred years, and his ‘therapy’ has no actual basis in science or medical fact. He devised this ‘therapy’ pretty much as soon as he graduated…with banknotes flickering across his eyes, no doubt. It scares me that shit like this is some people’s ONLY encounter with information about ME/CFS, and this is what they make their judgements on. To ‘Dr’ Asshole and those who believe his lies – fuck you. No seriously. FUCK YOU. You are an insidious creeping evil and your attitude causes more pain or suffering than any symptom I have ever experienced. On behalf of all ME/CFS patients who have ever had to deal with shit-for-brains money-grabbing cunts like you, F-U-C-K Y-O-U.

16 Comments »

  Rachel M wrote @

I didn’t click on his website on purpose coz I know I will not be able to control my anger.
I felt your frustration. I’ve been there, too. It took me ong time to realise that they were just brain washing me to believe that my symptoms were there because they were conveniernt excuse for me to stop living. (You expressed well how I felt, so I will not repeat them here.) Ironically, I took their advise very seriously coz I wanted to get better, and my health was completely destroyed.
Dr Reverse Therapy didn’t define ME/CFS properly and in my opinion, his definition falls into clinical depression. From the beginning, he is misleading potential victims, who are desperate enough to fork out expensive consultation fees and who usually does not have the moeny at the first place.
His treatment may cure some of clinically depressed patients. And I am very happy for those who cured by his therapy. But I just can’t accept the fact that he is falsely marketing his treatment to wrong patients who would suffer damage from his treatment. Morally it is a crime. But I am sure he and his money are protected by small print disclosures.
Everytime I see current affair type TV program introducing miracle cure with misleading definition of ME/CFS with so called cured ‘non ME/CFS sufferer’, I cannot stop myself feeling very angry. They have no idea how much dmage they just caused to the possibility of actual cure and reputation of people who are living with actual ME/CFS.

Thank you for bringing this up for us. I believe it is important to educate ourselves (and general public if we could) not to fall into such a scam.

  rachelcreative wrote @

It’s a contentious one that’s for sure. Reverse Therapy, Mickel Therapy and Lightning Process are all in a similiar school and there’s a real vibe of ‘if it doesn’t work it’s you that’s the problem’. I’ve seen huge, bitter discussions about it online by CFS sufferers. I understand these therapies have helped a lot of people who have made ‘a full recovery’ in a short amount of time. Other articles I have read suggest that in the long term the effects do not last, or that the recovered people have found a way to live activiely within their limitations.

Those cured by these treatments do not tend to talk about how it works (as talking about CFS seemingly jeopordises continued success).

I am not convinced that these therapies cure CFS. I am more inclined to believe they enable long term sufferers who have made a good physical recovery but are stuck in a loop of not believing they are well and perhaps in brainwashing others to mask the physical symptoms to god knows what end. I find the issies more confusing since I have an online friend who has recently experimented with the NLP principles behind some of these therapies and has so far had success – which mystifies me.

There was a good balanced article about the Lightning Process I think in the last AFME newsletter. Reaction and reports of success (short and long term) were mixed.

I personally avoid reading or talking about these therapies as it just causes me stress and anger (like you) – which I am sure the ‘experts’ would argue is a clear sign of denial and needing to accept what my mindbody-blah-blah says.

I find it highly distressing – particularly becuase in the UK the most newspaper coverage I have seen in the last year has been in nationals about success of these various therapies. That makes concerned relatives and friends cut out the articles and offer them to me as a ray of hope – when in reality it just serves to undermine the very real medical, physical, neurological, endocrine and immune problems we have.

  marilyn’s shampoo wrote @

great post tanya.

having never been personally affected by this and having only known one person before you (albeit not very well) who has suffered from it my opinions previously were – i admit it – clouded by the reportage of it as a psychological condition. not aided by the fact that the one person i knew previously fell into the unhappy/dragging themselves around category before they were ill. but knowing you has completely opened my eyes – you are like the living proof that (like that other great evil homosexuality) it’s not just a lifestyle choice ;)

“When I feel tired and worn out, I can rest or meditate. When I am in pain I can do stretches that ease my pain, or (god forbid!) take a couple of pain killers so that I can continue with the things I need to do. When I feel stressed (yes, anxious!) I can sit down, have a cup of tea, get my thoughts in order and remind myself that things aren’t as bad as they seem right now and I just need to take some time to chill out and deal with what’s going on. Does that sound like a conclusion that there is nothing I can do about my symptoms? No.”

this is key. the fact that you are pro-active not only in managing your symptoms but in enjoying your life if total proof that the ilness is against your will and not some invention of your subconcious.

like you say it may work for people who have been misdiagnosed and are really clinically depressed or it may ease the symptoms of those who are both – i’m sure it is easy to become depressed as a result of the illness.

however it is dangerous as it perpetuates the myth that it is ‘all in you head’

also you would have to be the therapy type of person for it to work at all – and frankly most smart, cynical people just can’t swing with that kind of thing. (most of it, especially the mickey-mouse stuff, is just stating the obvious to someone who deep down knows what they need to do anyway) unlike real medicine which actually works no matter what.

like you say if it works for some people fine, but i just wish they were honest about what they were doing (helping depressed/anxious sufferers cope with their illness) than claiming to cure it.

anyways, that was my uneducated opinion!

  Ina/cfs wrote @

You mention chocolate – was that on purpose? I kid you not, an article came out on – the Guardian? or another brit newspaper, about how ME/CFS could improve with one piece of chocolate every day – fuck them

  Valerie wrote @

Thanks very much for your highly accurate account of the experience of CFS, and the critique of Reverse Therapy. I’d been considering buying ‘Dr.’ Eaton’s book because there really is a connection between the brain/mind and body. Although, I was suspicious because of the ‘C’ word ‘cure’. And I do not believe you can think yourself well, but attitude does effect your level of function. Anger and anxiety are great energy wasters. I searched Google for any negative/objective views on RT. Yours was the first I found and I need look no further. Some may think that your anger clouds your objectivity, but I know too well the source of that anger – reality.
I’ve had CFS for 9 yrs. and have learned how to live within my limitations. My nursing knowledge helped with this monumental task. I’ve done many of the things suggested in RT (in nursing it’s called ‘coping mechanisms’) simply because I don’t want to be a miserable sick person; I want to be a happy sick person. I delegate many chores. I let the cleaning slide.I ask for help. I sew as much as I can. Sewing is the one activity from my old life that I can still do without exhaustion. I love sewing/quilting. It gives me a sense of accomplishment, value, etc. And the fabrics are gorgeous, as are my quilts (self pat-on-back; see? confidence booster).Although the layering part of quilt construction is exhausting. I do some half-assed meditation. I avoid stressful situations. I avoid most bad food (most, I said. I do like sweets and they make me happy). I try to quit before fatigue gets too bad, but sewing distracts me to the point of sore throat – a sign of ‘over did it’(I absolutely quit then – message of symptom). I take Xanax to minimize anxiety which I feel in a physical way even when I’m happily sewing.
I no longer feel trapped by CFS because I’ve learned to focus on what I can do and enjoy that as much as I can.
But despite all I’ve done to maximize my function, energy-wise: 1/2 hour of vacuuming still equals 4 hours of sewing. I still can’t shovel snow, do yard work, (10 min. of weeding makes walking difficult). My cognitive function is better, but that’s because my 2 kids are now grown and moved out – less commotion.
As for “all in you head”, literally it is. It’s a messed up brain. After much reading, I’ve come to the conclusion that a virus gets past the blood brain barrier, has a party in your brain and leaves you to clean up the mess and repair the damage. But the damage is too great to repair.
As for the chocolate cure – any excuse to eat choc. is cool with me.
Reading all these posts did not make me one bit angry. I’m smiling broadly at seeing my own feelings and experiences with CFS expressed so well.

  Mary Brown wrote @

I would just say try it before you slag it off!

  Tanya wrote @

Mary – I think it’s rather obvious why I wouldn’t waste my money ‘trying’ it. I disagree with the entire basis of the ‘therapy’ and therefore have no reason whatsoever to try it, what with my complete lack of belief in the fundamentally flawed logic that it’s based on.

  Julie wrote @

Hi, I don’t know much about ME but my friend’s wife had been a sufferer for years and years, could barely function or care for her child. My friend is a sober, pragmatic, cynical type of person who’d lost hope for her. She did 6 sessions with Dr Eaton and is now so well that she’s looking for a job! Who knows what works? I’ll try to update in a couple of months with her progress

Julie

  Tanya wrote @

Julie – I have two jobs and I have M.E. Having this condition doesn’t actually make it impossible to have a job. It makes it difficult to have a job. It makes is necessary to be selective about the type of job you have. But it’s not impossible, and a person doesn’t actually require expensive bullshit ‘therapy’ to do it.

And as for ‘who knows what works?’, doctors who have experience in dealing with patients with ME do have a pretty good idea what works. Unfortunately they’re few and far between, and no doubt the desperation felt after seeing a useless doctor makes the alternative ‘treatments’ seem a whole lot more appealing.

  Jess wrote @

I’ve not read all of this. Just some of the first and second posts…

I had Mickel Therapy for M.E. and I’m doing fantastic. Over 19 years of illness, it was the only thing out of many many many things (medical, psychological and alternative-I’m an expert on all the options!) that had any lasting and true effect. When I was last ill, I was two years in bed. Now, I’m at uni, working, absolutely thriving, and ran a half marathon on Sunday!! I’d never done sport much in my life before now, cos it was so difficult! Everything is fab now. It wasn’t easy to get better at first but I worked very hard at it (as I always had) and MT just gave me the tools that I needed :) I know, now, I can do absolutely anything I want to in life, and nothing can stop me :) Getting better was so exciting and became easier and easier and more and more fun :)

I’ve just turned 24…

Oh, and I wantes to write this, initially, just to say that the Lightning Process and M.E. are entirely different. I don’t rate LP at all :( That’s a treatment that’s a quick fix and doesn’t treat from the core. It’s advanced NLP basically. I had lots of NLP when i was ill. I have friends who did LP but have now turned to MT because LP only got them a short way and they were still i the ‘ill’ mindset/had food intolerances stil etc etc.

Good luck to everyone getting better and big higs to all those ill at the moment. It’s very hard but you can turn it all around and come out of it stronger. (I probably would’ve been pissed off at someone who’d said that to me when i was ill though, cos i was trying very hard to get better… i didn’t feel it was easily in my power to ‘turn it around.’ I do understand those strong feelings… But after winter, must come spring. There is always light at the end of the tunnel etc etc blah blah.. that must sound so patronising and corny lol.

  Jess wrote @

*LP and MT are different, that should read! :)

Also, I never had any energy, my whole life long. I could never do what my mates could do, even when i was feeling a bit better (late nights etc). Now, no one can keep up with me!! :) I can keep going for days! :)

  Jess wrote @

*Big Hugs, I meant!!! Lol, my typing is ridiculous!! Sorry; please excuse typos!

  Jess wrote @

ok, another line… just to say M.T. is not ‘therapy’ as you might think of that word; defintely not :)

  Jess wrote @

wow, i’ve just read a bit more more of this, and i’m shocked by people’s cynicism. lol. i might just give up now on people who are just never going to be interested in M.T. One thing i must say is that, yes, treatments like that do perpetuate the myth that it’s ‘all in yout head.’ Trust me, after THAT long of being ill, and that many ridiculous doctors trying to tell me as much, there was no way i was doing a treatment which said the same thing to me – and luckily MT actually doesn’t (it just might sound as if it does – but it definitely treats it as the physical illness that it is)x

  Tanya wrote @

Jess – I’m very happy that you’re getting better after being ill for 19 years. While it’s great that you’ve found something that works for you, it’s understandable how people may feel cynical about any treatment that says “Headmind notices that symptoms are getting worse so it triggers an Anxiety response that leads the person to conclude that there is nothing they can do about the symptoms” among other things.

I don’t want to just repeat my blog entry, but without forking out thousands for any expensive therapy I have managed to make adjustments to my activities and work with my body rather than against it to lead as normal a life as I can…including full-time work in a job I love as well as being able to socialise and exercise. Maybe my headmind and my bodymind are more in sync than the ‘therapists’ assume :)

  Sylvia wrote @

Hear hear! I don’t know where alternative practitioners get off charging huge amounts of money with no guarantee of results. If they really believe in it, they should only accept payment when the job is done.

Funny how despite all the success stories and the bazillions of dollars/pounds they’re making from it, they can’t seem to afford to run proper clinical trials to prove that it works. That only means one thing.

We should be putting our thousands into real medical research, not quackery.


Your comment

HTML-Tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>